REVIEW OF VECTORWORKS 2015
By John Helm Architect
The newest version of Vectorworks (VW) is out and as usual there are many new features to consider. In fact there are too many to cover in a single review. What I typically do is start using the program then take a look at the various changes and additions. I then choose a few that look like they would be interesting, solve some past problems or most importantly make it easier and faster to get my work done. I focus mostly on architecture for the obvious reason that I’m an architect and I look at things from a practical aspect leaving the highly technical issues up to those reviewers who have a better understanding of them.
You might say it’s about time. I mean it’s been around for a long time, even my 12 year old Windows XP desktop was 64 bit. However, forgiving the lateness it is still a big improvement and should make everything run smoother and faster. Being more compatible with commonly used processors has to be a good thing.
I mention a bit more about open GL below, but in general it seems that they have made open GL the de facto mode for use in 3D design. Can I say it’s wonderful? Yes, it makes working in 3D a pleasure. Easily go from a 2D plan view to 3D. Then work your model. Change things, move around, fly over and hold down the B key to get a quick wire frame view. Select an object to modify it, add color, add texture or change its size and see the results instantly. Now we can even use the shift key and arrows to move an object while watching it move in 3D. And the quality of the rendering when you include, show shadows and textures is starting to compete with final quality Renderworks.
Here’s my high rise design
Text Styles by Class
Here’s a nifty little item, assign text styles to a class, size, font, etc. Then either go to the class before typing your text or change the class after typing. This makes it easier to be consistent and keep an office set of text standards. What’s not to like.
Crop PDF pages
So much of what we get these days is in PDF format. Now it seems faster and easier to import a PDF file and use it for reference or as a base for tracing a floor plan. But it was in the past kind of a pain to modify the part of the file we wanted to include in our drawings. Now it’s easy. Import the whole file then crop it as we like. This makes it easy to use parts of a file in more than one place as reference for details, pictures, and plans or elevations of the existing in a remodel for example. Or include a picture of a specified product.
Rectangle Wall Mode
I like this a lot. Just select your wall type, and then draw rectangles to make the walls. This works great when drawing over a sketch imported as a PDF or drawing over a layout made with the space tool. When done the trim tool can be used to quickly clean out the un-needed walls.
Anyone doing commercial design will love the curtain wall feature. Here you can now draw the curtain wall without having to manually input vertical and horizontal mullions. It’s all done automatically and the best part is that you can change your mind and make changes later without having to start all over again.
Speed of rendering and open GL
There certainly seems a big improvement when using open GL. Flying around a model, changing views and doing virtual walkthrus seem almost flawless and fast. However I did do my own little comparison test of the model shown below using VW 2014 vs 2015. Doing a hidden line rendering took 4 to 5 seconds in 2015 and 4 in 2014. Doing a final quality Renderworks rendering took in minutes 2: 47 in 2015 and 1:47 in 2014. The model I used was first made in 2014 then imported into 2015. I made a lot of changes to it then exported it back to 2014 in order to have something the same in both versions. I don’t know if this qualifies as an accurate test or not. The picture shown here is the one done in version 2015 and I think it is a bit nicer looking than the one done with the older version. Some things are a lot better for example the windshield of the Corvette is transparent in 2015 but not in 2014. I can’t explain why the new version took so much longer to render, perhaps I need to change some settings.
Final Renderworks rendered model with much improved tree symbols
There is always a lot of talk about which program is best for BIM and I won’t attempt to answer the question. What I want to say is that what most of us make are not Building Information Models they are really just Building Models. VW lets us make models without restrictions of just about anything we can imagine. When we make a building model there is a certain amount of information, maybe a lot of information that just comes from the fact that we have a 3D view of the project which can be looked at from a multitude of angles and positions. I suppose you can call that information. But VW comes alive in BIM when we start using the actual information tools that are built into the software. Something as simple as a door can contain every bit of information one might want to know about the door, its material, door knobs, hinges, finish material and its cost. All of this information can be output to an automatically created door schedule for example. Of course, inputting all the information takes time and that’s where the whole BIM thing starts to get shall I say difficult. I mean who is going to pay me to do all that extra work. This takes us to the crux of the BIM movement. Can I export my model to a spec writer, who will do that work and an estimator who will crunch the numbers using my model imported into an estimating package. Can my model be then used by the structural and mechanical engineers to include their designs. The VW people say it can. But I have to admit that it’s beyond the scope of this article to test. Perhaps I’ll do a little test for another article.
Memory and crashing Issues
An old problem that doesn’t seem to want to go away is that the program sucks up memory and won’t let go. Doing a lot of 3D work or rendering and all of a sudden my undo cache says there are no more undos. This is a problem, for if you make a mistake you can’t go back and the only way to fix it is to close and restart VW. Sometimes restarting the computer is also required. My computer is not the latest but it’s not bad, Windows 8.1 Core I7, 8 gb of ram and a 1gb Geforce video card. I have also had a few crashes.
Here is a nifty improvement. Now it is very easy to import 3DS or SKI files. So those great 3D drawings you can find in 3D Warehouse or Turbosquid can be easily incorporated into your Resources. Check out the Corvette I imported in the drawing below and compare it to the typical car symbol next to it.
Rendered view showing a Sketchup model imported into Vectorworks
While looking at the Corvette also have a look at the trees; there are new landscape props available that are much more realistic. They render quickly and look great.
You can also notice the realistic people prop from my own collection of People Props for Vectorworks. They can be purchased here: www.helpudesign.blogspot.com or you can also see a video at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y2yVspkOsAw
Here’s a tool that has been around for a while that I haven’t talked about much in the past. This can be a time saver and also make exploring various options at the schematic design stage much faster which allows one to explore more potential solutions. The best way to use this is to make a program for your project. It doesn’t matter if it is a simple house or a complex office building. Create a spread sheet outside of VW with columns listing all the rooms in your building, with sizes and areas. Then save it as a comma separated file. Import into VW and it creates an adjacency matrix and rectangles for each space. Now you can move the spaces around, reshape them, etc. to create the floor plan. Then automatically create walls.
This could be a very powerful tool. There are some features I would change. For example when you manually make a space there is no read out of the length and width as when drawing normal rectangles. I would change that and also it would be great to get a read out of the total area as one draws the space. Or how about creating an option to keep a space the same size area wise no matter how you reshape.
Actually it has a way to go before it can be really useful. In fact I had a hard time understanding how to use it. Making a matrix on a spread sheet is tedious and difficult too much so for any kind of complex project. The VW help file is useless. I did find better instructions by searching on Google. But then after trying it a few times VW crashed so I decided to forget about it for now. I think it is useful if you make a list of the spaces in a spread sheet import it into VW then delete the matrix and then move the spaces manually.
Clip cube Caps
The clip cube is an important tool, it is used to make sections easily and it also lets you quickly cut open your model anyplace you want and even dynamically move the cut around while your client watches in amazement. In previous versions the cut line would show the hollow walls, floors and roofs. Now they added a cap at the cut line which just looks a lot nicer.
This has been around for a while but with the latest improvements it just gets better. Use the multiple viewports tool, to create hidden line views of the elevations and the roof plan. If you make changes just update the viewports. Turn layers and classes off or on as needed. Use annotation to add notes and dimensions. Textured surfaces in your model will now show up with automatic hatches if you use the proper textures. My model used for this test needs a little more work, but you can get the idea.
3D Hatching for hidden line rendering
This is another one of those important new features than can really make a difference. At first it doesn’t seem such a big deal. But remember how you had to add a hatch to an elevation. Draw a polygon around an area of the elevation then find the right hatch to apply. Do it enough times and you’re really going to get bored. Now what happens if you make changes in the elevations or worse yet you change the 3D model and use it to revise the elevations. Go back and revise all those polygons and hope you don’t miss any. With this new feature many of the textures come with premade hatches. So when you do a hidden line rendering the hatch magically appears and if you change the model it changes automatically.
Open GL rendered view Hidden line rendering (my model needs a fascia)
The built in help system is very good, even if there are a few places that need improvement. It is easy to access and you can just search for what you need to do. But I have complained in the past that they don’t do printed manuals anymore. Now they supply a disk with the program, called “Getting Started Guides”. It seems very good. There are tutorials that take you through most of the basics, and there are pdf files which are accompanied by videos. Their research told them that most users like to see how things are done on a video so they did the videos and also included the pdf files repeating what is in the videos which can be printed or viewed on the computer.
The biggest item not addressed once again is how do several designers work on a project at the same time. If you search the VW website you will find a nice little explanation of how to get multiple designers working on the same project. It can be done and those big firms in Japan where VW has captured most of the CAD market must be doing it successfully. But still it’s not easy. VW still in some ways seems to be a small shop tool. Perhaps they want to keep it that way so the parent company can sell its other products. But if they asked me, I’d tell them to spend the next year fixing this problem.
Other improvements not covered.
I could go on for many more pages. The important thing to note is that there is a lot of good stuff in this new release some small and some that make a big difference. Here is a list of some of the items I have not written about. Some speak for themselves and others you can read about in the VW help files or on their web site.
New level constraint system
Variable Tab Widths
Text under Dimensions
Outside Mode for Text
Dimension Text Position in Viewports
Elevation Benchmark Improvements
Callout Tool improvements
Drawing Label Improvements
Notes Manager Improvements
Better 3D Working
More Advanced 3D Modeling Tools
Working Planes Palette
Easier to use stair tool
Spaces Easier to Manage
More Control over Door and Window objects
Better Site Modeling
More Accurate Planting
Worksheet Improvements Worksheet menus
More Control over Stories
Better Control over Walls
Wire frame viewing improvements
There are two groups to consider. The first, those just getting CAD or those thinking to change systems and the second current users of VW who need to decide if it’s worth upgrading to the latest version.
For the first group if you main consideration is choosing the best program to get your work done and make it easier to express your creativity VW could be your first choice.
For the second group if you are just doing 2D drawings maybe your current version is good enough. But if you are into or want to get into 3D modeling and design and or BIM then why short change yourself for a few bucks. The improvements in open GL alone are enough to make it worth the change. The only problem is that every year now they are making so many improvements that it takes time to really get into them.
Let’s not forget that a CAD program is just a tool, like the pencil and paper used to be, or still is. We need a lot of tools to get the job done and we can buy various software programs, like Photoshop, AutoCAD, etc. Or we can buy one program that has them all. Vectorworks is not just a CAD or BIM tool; it is really the nearly perfect and complete toolbox for just about every architect or designer. From preliminary design to photo realistic renderings and construction drawings it has all the tools in one package.
In general VW makes working almost fun. Well yeah you would rather be fishing, skiing, or messing with your partner/spouse, but using the tools that come with the program really makes designing , presenting and even doing construction documents faster, more intuitive, and enjoyable. The better you get with the program the more fun it is and every year it just gets better.